
Boxers are the original men's underwear: loose legs, a button or elastic fly and plenty of air. They are also the cut most men have quietly stopped buying, which is a shame, because a good pair beats a tight one on a hot day.
Below: the brands that make a proper boxer, with a ranking that fills in only from our wear-test scores. Until then it is alphabetical, and we would rather show a blank than fake a podium.
The short answer
Our pick lands here once the wear-test is done. Until then, nothing on this page is ranked, and we would rather show you a blank than fake a winner.
The boxers ranking
Every pair in this style we have worn and scored. Scores come from our wear-tests only; pairs we have not worn are on public consensus instead. See all four ranking tables.
| Rank | Brand & model | Overall | Comfort | Pouch | Fabric | Style | Durability | Waistband | Value | From | Reviewed | Shop |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | BombasMen's Cotton Modal Blend BoxerThe best boxer we have worn: perfect 10s for comfort and style, so it looks as good as it feels. Prefer a closer cut? Bombas' slim fit fit us beautifully too. | 9.4 | 10 | — | 9 | 10 | 9 | 9 | 9.2 | $28 | Nov 20, 2026 New | Link soon |
| 2 | Mack Weldon18-Hour Jersey Knit BoxerNines for comfort, fabric, style and durability. A boxer sharp enough to be seen in; only the waistband (7) holds it back. | 8.7 | 9 | — | 9 | 9 | 9 | 7 | 8.1 | $34 | Nov 20, 2026 New | Link soon |
| 3 | Calvin KleinCotton Classics 3-Pack Knit BoxerClassic Calvin Klein knit with a 9 for the waistband. Dependable rather than daring. | 8.0 | 8 | — | 8 | 8 | 7 | 9 | 8.7 | $52.50 3-pack | Nov 20, 2026 New | Link soon |
| 4 | Tommy JohnWoven Boxer (3-Pack)A tidy woven boxer with straight 8s for comfort, fabric, durability and waistband. Style (7) is where it plays it safe. | 7.9 | 8 | — | 8 | 7 | 8 | 8 | 8.3 | $59.50 3-pack | Nov 20, 2026 New | Link soon |
Overall = 90% quality (our six wear-test scores, weighted; five for boxers, which have no Pouch score) + 10% Value. Value is worked out from quality and the regular price per pair (how). Prices: regular listed price on the brand’s own product page or public product feed, retrieved Nov 19–20, 2026. Packs are marked and are not per-pair prices (hover for basis). “Check brand page” means we could not verify a price. † = price from a retailer listing, not the brand’s own site. Prices change.
How to choose
Woven or knit
Woven cotton is crisp and breathable. Knit boxers feel like a tee for your legs. Pick by how you sleep and sit.
Fly or no fly
Button flies are classic. Many modern pairs skip the fly and keep the cut simple.
Length
Inseams vary a lot. Short ones sit under shorts. Long ones double as sleepwear.
Waistband
Covered elastic sits flat. Exposed elastic digs less when it is wide.