Gentleman's DrawerBetter underwear, properly judged
Split image: pale folded stack on navy fabric, dark folded stack on burgundy fabric
20 pairs wear-tested

The brand rankings.

Four tables, six wear-test scores plus Value, one honest number. Boxers, boxer briefs, trunks and briefs, ranked from our wear-tests and nothing else.

Only pairs our tester has worn, washed and scored make these tables. Each new pair joins with the date we reviewed it, and wears a “New” badge for its first 30 days. Click any pair for the full review. Pairs we have not worn yet are on public consensus, with customer ratings and nothing from us.

How the number works

Each pair is scored 0 to 10 on six things, weighted into a quality score. Value is worked out from quality and the regular price per pair. Overall = 90% quality + 10% Value. Weights: Comfort 20% · Pouch 15% · Fabric 15% · Style 15% · Durability 15% · Waistband 10% · Value 10%. Full method on How we test. No score is ever estimated or borrowed from another site.

Boxers

Classic woven and loose-cut boxers.

4 pairs wear-testedOnly pairs we have worn. Style = how sharp it looks on, 0-10. Click a column to sort. Pairs we have not worn: public consensus.
RankBrand & modelOverallComfortPouchFabricStyleDurabilityWaistbandValueFromReviewedShop
1BombasMen's Cotton Modal Blend BoxerThe best boxer we have worn: perfect 10s for comfort and style, so it looks as good as it feels. Prefer a closer cut? Bombas' slim fit fit us beautifully too.9.410—910999.2$28Nov 20, 2026 NewLink soon
2Mack Weldon18-Hour Jersey Knit BoxerNines for comfort, fabric, style and durability. A boxer sharp enough to be seen in; only the waistband (7) holds it back.8.79—99978.1$34Nov 20, 2026 NewLink soon
3Calvin KleinCotton Classics 3-Pack Knit BoxerClassic Calvin Klein knit with a 9 for the waistband. Dependable rather than daring.8.08—88798.7$52.50 3-packNov 20, 2026 NewLink soon
4Tommy JohnWoven Boxer (3-Pack)A tidy woven boxer with straight 8s for comfort, fabric, durability and waistband. Style (7) is where it plays it safe.7.98—87888.3$59.50 3-packNov 20, 2026 NewLink soon

Overall = 90% quality (our six wear-test scores, weighted; five for boxers, which have no Pouch score) + 10% Value. Value is worked out from quality and the regular price per pair (how). Prices: regular listed price on the brand’s own product page or public product feed, retrieved Nov 19–20, 2026. Packs are marked and are not per-pair prices (hover for basis). “Check brand page” means we could not verify a price. † = price from a retailer listing, not the brand’s own site. Prices change.

Boxer Briefs

The everyday default: support with leg coverage.

5 pairs wear-testedOnly pairs we have worn. Style = how sharp it looks on, 0-10. Click a column to sort. Pairs we have not worn: public consensus.
RankBrand & modelOverallComfortPouchFabricStyleDurabilityWaistbandValueFromReviewedShop
1Tommy JohnCool Cotton Mid-Length Boxer Brief 6"Our top boxer brief: a 9 for comfort, 8s across the board, and a horizontal fly that is a genuine highlight.8.29888887.6$34Nov 20, 2026 NewLink soon
2lululemonAlways In Motion Boxer Brief 5"Athletic polish with a 9 for the waistband and 8s almost everywhere else. Looks as sharp as it feels.7.98888797.3$34Nov 20, 2026 NewLink soon
3Calvin KleinCotton Stretch 3-Pack Boxer BriefThe timeless classic. Not our favorite, but never the wrong answer, and the logo waistband earns a 9.7.37687798$52.50 3-packNov 20, 2026 NewLink soon
4Mack Weldon18-Hour Jersey Boxer BriefA good pouch (8) and solid durability, let down by a waistband that scored a 6.7.27877866.8$30Nov 20, 2026 NewLink soon
5BombasMen's Cotton Modal Blend Boxer Brief 6"Flyless and smooth up front with a good waistband (8). Comfortable enough, but style (6) is modest.6.97776786.7$28Nov 20, 2026 NewLink soon

Overall = 90% quality (our six wear-test scores, weighted; five for boxers, which have no Pouch score) + 10% Value. Value is worked out from quality and the regular price per pair (how). Prices: regular listed price on the brand’s own product page or public product feed, retrieved Nov 19–20, 2026. Packs are marked and are not per-pair prices (hover for basis). “Check brand page” means we could not verify a price. † = price from a retailer listing, not the brand’s own site. Prices change.

Trunks

A shorter leg with boxer-brief support.

4 pairs wear-testedOnly pairs we have worn. Style = how sharp it looks on, 0-10. Click a column to sort. Pairs we have not worn: public consensus.
RankBrand & modelOverallComfortPouchFabricStyleDurabilityWaistbandValueFromReviewedShop
1Tommy JohnUltra Soft Flex Trunk 4" trunkOur top trunk and a true drawer staple: 9s for comfort, pouch and fabric. Always a great pair.8.59998888.3$28Nov 20, 2026 NewLink soon
2lululemonAlways In Motion Boxer Brief 3" 3" inseamThe trunk partners notice. In our experience women love a man in these, and comfort scored a perfect 10.lululemon has no style named trunk; this is its shortest leg8.310788897.7$34Nov 20, 2026 NewLink soon
3Mack Weldon18-Hour Jersey Trunk trunkA great everyday trunk with a 9 for comfort and a clean, sharp look (8 for style).8.19888877.9$28Nov 20, 2026 NewLink soon
4ObviouslyEveryMan Trunk trunkA perfect 10 for the pouch, so it flatters up front. The trade-off: the legs can ride up a little and the fabric runs warm.7.871077887.6$27Nov 20, 2026 NewLink soon

Overall = 90% quality (our six wear-test scores, weighted; five for boxers, which have no Pouch score) + 10% Value. Value is worked out from quality and the regular price per pair (how). Prices: regular listed price on the brand’s own product page or public product feed, retrieved Nov 19–20, 2026. Packs are marked and are not per-pair prices (hover for basis). “Check brand page” means we could not verify a price. † = price from a retailer listing, not the brand’s own site. Prices change.

Briefs

The classic cut, updated.

7 pairs wear-testedOnly pairs we have worn. Style = how sharp it looks on, 0-10. Click a column to sort. Pairs we have not worn: public consensus.
RankBrand & modelOverallComfortPouchFabricStyleDurabilityWaistbandValueFromReviewedShop
1Tommy JohnAir BriefOne of our all-time favorites: a flattering cut designed for men and a perfect 10 for fabric. The brief we would hand a skeptic.8.998109998.1$38Nov 20, 2026 NewLink soon
2ObviouslyEveryMan BriefBuilt to impress: a generous pouch (10) and a very flattering front in a bold cut that leaves little to the imagination. The rear could be better.8.081078787.9$26Nov 20, 2026 NewLink soon
3Mack Weldon18-Hour Jersey BriefShapes the seat nicely, so it looks good walking away. The waistband (6) leaves more to be desired.7.88698967.7$26Nov 20, 2026 NewLink soon
4lululemonAlways In Motion BriefA welcome surprise: lululemon made a brief, and it is a smart pick for men with bigger thighs. Waistband scored a 9.7.67787897.6$24Nov 20, 2026 NewLink soon
5Calvin KleinIcon Cotton Stretch 3-Pack BriefA classic staple: clean, familiar and easy to like.7.48687788.1$52.50 3-packNov 20, 2026 NewLink soon
6BombasMen's Cotton Modal Blend Flyless BriefDurable (9) with good fabric (8), but the fuller cut is not flattering on an athletic build. Style scored a 3.6.26483986.3$24Nov 20, 2026 NewLink soon
7JockeyClassic Full Rise Brief - 3 PackThe original men's brief. It has come a long way, but it still carries a stigma, and style scored a 2.5.86682657.8$26 3-packNov 20, 2026 NewLink soon

Overall = 90% quality (our six wear-test scores, weighted; five for boxers, which have no Pouch score) + 10% Value. Value is worked out from quality and the regular price per pair (how). Prices: regular listed price on the brand’s own product page or public product feed, retrieved Nov 19–20, 2026. Packs are marked and are not per-pair prices (hover for basis). “Check brand page” means we could not verify a price. † = price from a retailer listing, not the brand’s own site. Prices change.

Price sources

  1. Public Shopify product feeds on each brand's own site (Nov 19–20, 2026): Saxx, Tommy John, TBĂ´, Mack Weldon, CDLP, Druthers, Obviously.
  2. Brand product and collection pages (Nov 20, 2026): SKIMS, Bombas, Calvin Klein, Uniqlo, Duluth Trading Co, lululemon, Hugo Boss, Jockey. MeUndies: FeelFree Boxer Brief page (Nov 19, 2026).
  3. † Retailer listings, not the brand’s own site: Underwear Expert (HOM, Nov 19, 2026) and Revolve (Polo Ralph Lauren, Nov 20, 2026). A retailer’s price can differ from the brand’s own site.
  4. Calvin Klein prices are for 3-packs. Its regular prices were listed on its category pages, except the boxer brief, which is worked out from the 50% off shown on its product page. Sale prices change daily, so we show the regular price.