Gentleman's DrawerBetter underwear, properly judged
Underwear drawer, rolled and folded, in moody light
Public opinion, not our testing

Public consensus.

What customers say about every pair we track, worn by us or not: star ratings and review counts copied from the brand’s own review section, with a link and the date we checked.

Read this first

This page is not our wear-test. Star ratings are averages of customer reviews on the linked page, as shown on the date given. Brands moderate their own review sections, and small samples (under 20 reviews) are flagged. Where we found no rating we say so rather than guess. Our own scores live in the rankings, and only cover pairs we have worn.

26 of 55 pairs have a public star rating we could verify. 2 show zero reviews, and for 27 we have not found a rating yet. Summaries appear only where we read the reviews ourselves and can link them.

Boxers

PairCustomer ratingReviewsSourceWhat reviewers sayOur wear-test
Duluth Trading CoMen's Buck Naked Boxers★★★★★★★★★★ 4.6/5697Duluth Trading product page
Nov 20, 2026
No sourced summary yetNot worn by us yet
lululemonAlways In Motion Boxer 5"★★★★★★★★★★ 4.2/5800lululemon product page
Nov 20, 2026
No sourced summary yetNot worn by us yet
SKIMSCotton Poplin Men's Logo Band Boxer★★★★★★★★★★ 4.2/582SKIMS product page
Nov 20, 2026
No sourced summary yetNot worn by us yet
UniqloWoven Trunks | Broadcloth★★★★★★★★★★ 4.2/571Uniqlo US product listing
Nov 20, 2026
No sourced summary yetNot worn by us yet
JockeyClassics Full Cut 5" Boxer - 3 Pack★★★★★★★★★★ 4.1/5782Jockey product page
Nov 20, 2026
No sourced summary yetNot worn by us yet
Tommy JohnWoven Boxer (3-Pack)★★★★★★★★★★ 3.51/588Tommy John product page
Nov 20, 2026
Mixed. Highlighted reviews like the fit, the colors and the stretchy waistband; several recent reviewers found the cut roomy or baggy, and one says it runs large. sourceOur review: 7.9
Saxx24Seven Cotton Boxer Short★★★★★★★★★★ 3/5 small sample12Saxx product page
Nov 20, 2026
No sourced summary yetNot worn by us yet
BombasMen's Cotton Modal Blend BoxerNo rating found–Not found yetNo sourced summary yetOur review: 9.4
Calvin KleinCotton Classics 3-Pack Knit BoxerNo rating found–Not found yetNo sourced summary yetOur review: 8.0
CDLPBoxer ShortsNo rating found–Not found yetNo sourced summary yetNot worn by us yet
DruthersOrganic Cotton Shibori Clouds Boxer ShortsNo rating found–Not found yetNo sourced summary yetNot worn by us yet
Mack Weldon18-Hour Jersey Knit BoxerNo rating found–Not found yetNo sourced summary yetOur review: 8.7

Boxer Briefs

PairCustomer ratingReviewsSourceWhat reviewers sayOur wear-test
Duluth Trading CoMen's Buck Naked Boxer Briefs★★★★★★★★★★ 4.8/518,966Duluth Trading product page
Nov 20, 2026
No sourced summary yetNot worn by us yet
Tommy JohnCool Cotton Mid-Length Boxer Brief 6"★★★★★★★★★★ 4.57/52,107Tommy John product page
Nov 20, 2026
Highlighted reviews praise the fit, the material and a length that does not ride up. Some recent reviewers report loose threads or frayed waistbands, and inconsistent sizing. sourceOur review: 8.2
SKIMSCotton Men's 5" Boxer Brief★★★★★★★★★★ 4.5/5349SKIMS product page
Nov 20, 2026
No sourced summary yetNot worn by us yet
UniqloAIRism Boxer Briefs★★★★★★★★★★ 4.5/5109Uniqlo US product listing
Nov 20, 2026
No sourced summary yetNot worn by us yet
lululemonAlways In Motion Boxer Brief 5"★★★★★★★★★★ 4.4/549lululemon product page
Nov 20, 2026
lululemon's page rates the fit "True to size" based on reviews. Recent reviewers call it soft and breathable and several say it does not ride up. sourceOur review: 7.9
Tommy JohnUltra Soft Flex Mid-Length Boxer Brief 6"★★★★★★★★★★ 3.98/5140Tommy John product page (same 140 reviews shown on its Ultra Soft Flex trunk page)
Nov 20, 2026
Highlighted reviews praise the soft, light fabric. One recent reviewer says the legs keep riding up, one found the XL small, and one missed the wider waistband of an earlier version. The same 140 reviews appear on the Ultra Soft Flex trunk page. sourceNot worn by us yet
BombasMen's Cotton Modal Blend Boxer Brief 6"No rating found–Not found yetNo sourced summary yetOur review: 6.9
Calvin KleinCotton Stretch 3-Pack Boxer BriefNo rating found–Not found yetNo sourced summary yetOur review: 7.3
CDLPBoxer BriefNo rating found–Not found yetNo sourced summary yetNot worn by us yet
HanesUltimate Comfort Flex Fit Boxer Brief 4-PackNo rating found–Not found yetNo sourced summary yetNot worn by us yet
Hugo BossBOSS Three-pack stretch-cotton boxer briefsNo rating found–Not found yetNo sourced summary yetNot worn by us yet
Mack Weldon18-Hour Jersey Boxer BriefNo rating found–Not found yetNo sourced summary yetOur review: 7.2
MeUndiesUltraModal FeelFree Boxer BriefNo rating found–Not found yetNo sourced summary yetNot worn by us yet
ObviouslyEveryMan Boxer Brief 6 inch LegNo rating found–Not found yetNo sourced summary yetNot worn by us yet
Polo Ralph LaurenClassic Fit Cotton 3 Pack Boxer BriefNo rating found–Not found yetNo sourced summary yetNot worn by us yet
SaxxDropTemp® Cooling Mesh Boxer BriefNo rating found–Not found yetNo sourced summary yetNot worn by us yet

Trunks

PairCustomer ratingReviewsSourceWhat reviewers sayOur wear-test
CDLPBoxer Trunk★★★★★★★★★★ 5/5 small sample8CDLP product page
Nov 20, 2026
No sourced summary yetNot worn by us yet
SKIMSCotton Men's 3" Boxer Brief★★★★★★★★★★ 4.5/5282SKIMS product page
Nov 20, 2026
No sourced summary yetNot worn by us yet
TBôThe Hot Coral Trunk★★★★★★★★★★ 4.45/51,927TBô product page
Nov 20, 2026
No sourced summary yetNot worn by us yet
lululemonAlways In Motion Boxer Brief 3"★★★★★★★★★★ 4.3/5 small sample7lululemon product page
Nov 20, 2026
Fit based on reviews: "True to size". Reviewers praise the light, soft fabric; two of the seven reviews dislike the newer large logo waistband. sourceOur review: 8.3
Tommy JohnUltra Soft Flex Trunk 4"★★★★★★★★★★ 3.98/5140Tommy John product page (same 140 reviews shown on its Ultra Soft Flex boxer brief page)
Nov 20, 2026
Highlighted reviews praise the soft, light fabric. Several recent reviewers were disappointed it has no fly, and one says the legs keep riding up. The same 140 reviews appear on the Ultra Soft Flex boxer brief page. sourceOur review: 8.5
SaxxNon-Stop Stretch Cotton Trunk★★★★★★★★★★ 3.9/5413Saxx product page
Nov 20, 2026
No sourced summary yetNot worn by us yet
BombasMen's Cotton Modal Blend TrunkNo rating found–Not found yetNo sourced summary yetNot worn by us yet
Calvin KleinCotton Stretch 3-Pack Low Rise TrunkNo rating found–Not found yetNo sourced summary yetNot worn by us yet
HOMFremont TrunkNo rating found0Underwear Expert listing (retailer)
Nov 20, 2026
No sourced summary yetNot worn by us yet
Hugo BossBOSS 3-Pack TrunksNo rating found–Not found yetNo sourced summary yetNot worn by us yet
Mack Weldon18-Hour Jersey TrunkNo rating found–Not found yetNo sourced summary yetOur review: 8.1
ObviouslyEveryMan TrunkNo rating found–Not found yetNo sourced summary yetOur review: 7.8

Briefs

PairCustomer ratingReviewsSourceWhat reviewers sayOur wear-test
CDLPY-Brief★★★★★★★★★★ 5/5 small sample11CDLP product page
Nov 20, 2026
No sourced summary yetNot worn by us yet
SKIMSCotton Men's Brief★★★★★★★★★★ 4.6/5171SKIMS product page
Nov 20, 2026
No sourced summary yetNot worn by us yet
Tommy JohnAir Brief★★★★★★★★★★ 4.58/51,205Tommy John product page
Nov 20, 2026
Highlighted reviews praise the fit, comfort and light mesh; one says it finally gives Tommy John briefs a deep enough pouch. A few found it runs smaller and tighter than Tommy John's Second Skin. sourceOur review: 8.9
Duluth Trading CoMen's Buck Naked Briefs★★★★★★★★★★ 4.5/54,914Duluth Trading product page
Nov 20, 2026
No sourced summary yetNot worn by us yet
lululemonAlways In Motion Brief★★★★★★★★★★ 4.4/5 small sample9lululemon product page
Nov 20, 2026
Reviewers call it soft and comfortable. Sizing comments are mixed (one reviewer sized down, another sized up), and one notes a very high cut on the leg. sourceOur review: 7.6
TBôThe Hot Coral Brief★★★★★★★★★★ 4.38/52,348TBô product page
Nov 20, 2026
No sourced summary yetNot worn by us yet
Tommy JohnCool Cotton Brief★★★★★★★★★★ 4.36/51,577Tommy John product page
Nov 20, 2026
Highlighted reviews praise the feel, the fit and the horizontal fly. A minority of recent reviews report sizing or support problems. sourceNot worn by us yet
BombasMen's Cotton Modal Blend Flyless BriefNo rating found–Not found yetNo sourced summary yetOur review: 6.2
Calvin KleinIcon Cotton Stretch 3-Pack BriefNo rating found–Not found yetNo sourced summary yetOur review: 7.4
HOMBo Comfort Mini Brief Navy PrintNo rating found0Underwear Expert listing (retailer)
Nov 20, 2026
No sourced summary yetNot worn by us yet
Hugo BossBOSS Three-pack of logo-waistband briefs in stretch cottonNo rating found–Not found yetNo sourced summary yetNot worn by us yet
JockeyClassic Full Rise Brief - 3 PackNo rating found–Not found yetNo sourced summary yetOur review: 5.8
Mack Weldon18-Hour Jersey BriefNo rating found–Not found yetNo sourced summary yetOur review: 7.8
ObviouslyEveryMan BriefNo rating found–Not found yetNo sourced summary yetOur review: 8.0
SaxxNon-Stop Stretch Cotton BriefNo rating found–Not found yetNo sourced summary yetNot worn by us yet