Gentleman's DrawerBetter underwear, properly judged
Open cream gift box with two folded boxer briefs in navy and grey, tissue paper, green ribbon and a blank card
Verdicts coming

The gift guide: underwear upgrades he’ll actually wear

Shopping for a husband, partner, dad or brother? Here is how to pick a pair he will wear, and what to check before you buy.

By the Gentleman's Drawer team · Facts checked Nov 19, 2026

Underwear is one of the most useful gifts there is, and one of the easiest to get wrong. The usual mistakes are the wrong size, the wrong cut, or a pair far from anything he would pick himself.

This guide is a short checklist, followed by four pairs with facts taken from the brands’ own pages. Our verdicts follow after our wear-tests. Nothing here is ranked until then.

Verdict coming

The short answer

Our pick lands here once the wear-test is done. Until then, nothing on this page is ranked, and we would rather show you a blank than fake a winner.

The shortlist

Side by side

PairList priceSizesFabricPouchBrand-listed featuresOur verdict
Saxx
Vibe Xtra Soft Comfort Boxer Brief
$36 list (black; some colors discounted)XS to 4XLEcoVero fabric (composition percentages not on the feed; check brand page)BallPark Pouch with Stop Drop TechnologyNo-RideUp Leg, fly openingVerdict coming
Tommy John
Second Skin Boxer Brief 8"
$38 struck-through list price (showed a Final Sale price of $21 on the retrieval date)S to XXLModal stretch (percentages not on the feed)Contour PouchQuick Draw horizontal fly, Stay-Put waistband, tagless label, brand says non-pillingVerdict coming
MeUndies
UltraModal FeelFree Boxer Brief
$26 single, $78 for a 3-pack, $156 for a 6-pack (pack discounts shown on the site)Size menu on brand page (a Zappos listing for a related Feel Free Boxers style shows SM, MD, XL, 2XL; verify)Modal. A Zappos listing for a related Feel Free Boxers style says 92% micro modal / 8% elastane (not verified for this exact product)No pouch name given on this pageFabric-covered, pinch-free waistband per brand copyVerdict coming
TBo
The TBo Black Brief (single)
$13 on the retrieval date (struck-through $26)XS to XXL, listed by waist (25 to 44 inches across the range)95% bamboo viscose / 5% spandexManShaped pouchAdaptive waistbandVerdict coming

Price, size, fabric, pouch and feature columns are what the brand page said on Nov 19, 2026. They are not test results. The verdict column fills in after our wear-test.

How to choose

Find his size first

Check the label on a pair he already wears. Waist size is the one to match, and brand charts differ, so check the size chart of the pair you are buying.

Stay close to what he wears

If he lives in boxer briefs, buy boxer briefs. A gift is not the time to introduce a new cut.

Choose a calm colour

Navy, charcoal and black are safe. Save the bold prints for when you know his taste.

Check the returns

Look at the brand’s return and exchange policy before you order, in case the size is off.

The contenders in detail

Close-up of soft grey modal knit with a ribbed waistbandAI illustration
No. 1 · gift idea

Saxx Vibe Xtra Soft Comfort Boxer Brief

Verdict coming

What the brand page says (Nov 19, 2026):

Price
$36 list (black; some colors discounted)
Sizes
XS to 4XL
Fabric
EcoVero fabric (composition percentages not on the feed; check brand page)
Pouch
BallPark Pouch with Stop Drop Technology
Features
No-RideUp Leg, fly opening
ComfortComing
PouchComing
FabricComing
WaistbandComing
Check price at SaxxBrand page (plain link)

Link pending. If it becomes an affiliate link, this line will say so: "We may earn a commission if you buy through this link."

Underwear drawer, rolled and folded, in moody lightAI illustration
No. 2 · gift idea

Tommy John Second Skin Boxer Brief 8"

Verdict coming

What the brand page says (Nov 19, 2026):

Price
$38 struck-through list price (showed a Final Sale price of $21 on the retrieval date)
Sizes
S to XXL
Fabric
Modal stretch (percentages not on the feed)
Pouch
Contour Pouch
Features
Quick Draw horizontal fly, Stay-Put waistband, tagless label, brand says non-pilling
ComfortComing
PouchComing
FabricComing
WaistbandComing
Check price at Tommy JohnBrand page (plain link)

Link pending. If it becomes an affiliate link, this line will say so: "We may earn a commission if you buy through this link."

Neat stack of folded cotton underwear in sage, sand and greyAI illustration
No. 3 · gift idea

MeUndies UltraModal FeelFree Boxer Brief

Verdict coming

What the brand page says (Nov 19, 2026):

Price
$26 single, $78 for a 3-pack, $156 for a 6-pack (pack discounts shown on the site)
Sizes
Size menu on brand page (a Zappos listing for a related Feel Free Boxers style shows SM, MD, XL, 2XL; verify)
Fabric
Modal. A Zappos listing for a related Feel Free Boxers style says 92% micro modal / 8% elastane (not verified for this exact product)
Pouch
No pouch name given on this page
Features
Fabric-covered, pinch-free waistband per brand copy
ComfortComing
PouchComing
FabricComing
WaistbandComing
Check price at MeUndiesBrand page (plain link)

Link pending. If it becomes an affiliate link, this line will say so: "We may earn a commission if you buy through this link."

Fanned black, navy and charcoal boxer briefs on dark glassAI illustration
No. 4 · gift idea

TBo The TBo Black Brief (single)

Verdict coming

What the brand page says (Nov 19, 2026):

Price
$13 on the retrieval date (struck-through $26)
Sizes
XS to XXL, listed by waist (25 to 44 inches across the range)
Fabric
95% bamboo viscose / 5% spandex
Pouch
ManShaped pouch
Features
Adaptive waistband
ComfortComing
PouchComing
FabricComing
WaistbandComing
Check price at TBoBrand page (plain link)

Link pending. If it becomes an affiliate link, this line will say so: "We may earn a commission if you buy through this link."

Sources

  1. Saxx Vibe Xtra Soft Comfort Boxer Brief (black), product page, retrieved Nov 19, 2026
  2. Tommy John Second Skin Boxer Brief 8in, product page, retrieved Nov 19, 2026
  3. MeUndies UltraModal FeelFree Boxer Brief, product page, retrieved Nov 19, 2026
  4. TBo The TBo Black Brief, product page, retrieved Nov 19, 2026