
Tommy John Cool Cotton Mid-Length Boxer Brief 6"
Our top boxer brief: a 9 for comfort, 8s across the board, and a horizontal fly that is a genuine highlight.
Our take
Our top boxer brief. Comfort scored a 9 and everything else an 8, so there is no weak spot to apologise for. The horizontal fly is great, a genuine highlight. Per Tommy John it is 86% Pima cotton with its horizontal Quick Draw fly and a stay-put waistband. On us it looked smooth and polished, the kind of pair that makes getting dressed feel a little more intentional.
The scorecard
Scores are 0 to 10 from our own wear-test. Value is worked out from quality and the regular price per pair (how).
Where it shines
Comfort
Where it falls short
Nothing scored 6 or below.
On paper
What Tommy John says, checked Nov 20, 2026. These are the brand’s claims, not our test results.
- Pair
- Cool Cotton Mid-Length Boxer Brief 6"
- Regular price
- $34 (regular listed price)
- Detail
- 86% Pima cotton, 14% spandex
- Detail
- Horizontal Quick Draw fly
- Detail
- Stay-put waistband, per Tommy John
- Detail
- 6-inch inseam
- Source
- Tommy John page
Link pending. If it becomes an affiliate link, this line will say so, right here.
What buyers say
★★★★★★★★★★ 4.57/5 from 2,107 reviews · Tommy John product page, Nov 20, 2026
Highlighted reviews praise the fit, the material and a length that does not ride up. Some recent reviewers report loose threads or frayed waistbands, and inconsistent sizing. Read the reviews.
Public opinion from the brand’s own review section, not our testing. See every pair on our public consensus page.
Where it ranks
| Rank | Boxer Briefs we have worn | Overall |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | Tommy John Cool Cotton Mid-Length Boxer Brief 6" | 8.2 |
| 2 | lululemon Always In Motion Boxer Brief 5" | 7.9 |
| 3 | Calvin Klein Cotton Stretch 3-Pack Boxer Brief | 7.3 |
| 4 | Mack Weldon 18-Hour Jersey Boxer Brief | 7.2 |
| 5 | Bombas Men's Cotton Modal Blend Boxer Brief 6" | 6.9 |
Full boxer briefs table · More from Tommy John
How we got here
Our tester wore and washed this pair, then scored it on six things (five for boxers). We did not receive it from Tommy John for review. No score here is borrowed from another site. Images on this page are AI illustrations, not photos of this pair.